WHERE TREES SHOULD BE PLANTED – A Balanced View.
Very little root action leading to subsidence damage to buildings in the UK is caused by direct physical pressure exerted by roots. A tree has to be very close to the structure indeed for such damage to occur. Planting a tree so close to a structure that trunk buttressing or increase in trunk diameter was being restricted could lead to damage. More commonly, pavements and boundary walls with little or no foundation may be lifted by large shallow roots of, for example, Populus, poplar, species. Buildings with adequate foundations, standing some distance from trees, are very rarely subject to such direct damage.
Most reported damage is secondary in nature. The problem is confined largely to soil types that shrink considerably on drying. In the UK these are mainly certain types of clay and some peaty, fen soils. Under conditions of drought when tree roots remove water from shrinkable soils, they accelerate the drying and shrinking process. This can lead to loss of support to inadequate foundations and subsequent subsidence. Continued drought, even in the absence of trees, can lead to subsidence in such circumstances.
Tree root spread data have most relevance to relatively ‘safe’ planting distances when relating to trees growing on shrinkable clay soils. Planting distances on other soil types that do not contract on drying have to be determined more by consideration of the respective scale of the buildings and trees, the ultimate size of the trees, and the desirable or undesirable qualities of the trees concerned. In all cases it is wise to consult a qualified expert.
KEEPING A SENSIBLE DISTANCE
Table below shows the Minimum Distance from property and Maximum root spread recorded
| Cypress | Cupressus | Min – 3.5 metres | Max – 20.0 metres |
| Cypress | Chamaecyparis | Min – 3.5 metres | Max – 20.0 metres |
| Birch | Betula | Min – 4.0 metres | Max – 10.0 metres |
| Apple | Malus | Min – 5.0 metres | Max – 10.0 metres |
| Pair | Pyrus | Min – 5.0 metres | Max – 10.0 metres |
| Cherry, Plum and Peach | Prunus | Min – 6.0 metres | Max – 11.0 metres |
| Hawthorn | Crataegus | Min – 7.0 metres | Max – 11.5 metres |
| Rowan & Mountain Ash | Sorbus | Min – 7.0 metres | Max – 11.0 metres |
| Plane | Platanus | Min – 7.5 metres | Max – 15.0 metres |
| Lime | Tilia | Min – 8.0 metres | Max – 20.0 metres |
| Black-Locust | Robinia | Min – 8.5 metres | Max – 12.4 metres |
| Beech | Fagus | Min – 9.0 metres | Max – 15.0 metres |
| Ash | Fraxinus | Min – 10.0 metres | Max – 21.0 metres |
| Horse Chestnut | Aesculus | Min – 10.0 metres | Max – 23.0 metres |
| Elm | Ulmus | Min – 12.0 metres | Max – 25.0 metres |
| Maple & Sycamore | Acer | Min – 12.0 metres | Max – 20.0 metres |
| Oak | Quercus | Min – 18.0 metres | Max – 30.0 metres |
| Willow | Salix | Min – 18.0 metres | Max – 40.0 metres |
| Poplar | Populus | Min – 20.0 metres | Max – 30.0 metres |
Copyright Reserved © Subsidence Claims Advisory Bureau 1999
This page must not be reproduced without the written prior permission of the Bureau
Call us on 07596 695651 or 07770 598 712
email: rob@subsidencebureau.com 0r cover@prminsurance.co.uk
Subsidence Claims Advisory Bureau
9 Clevedon Road, Bexhill on Sea, East Sussex
TN39 4EL